Sarah Rice Teases All Stars Return

The future of All Stars may be uncertain at the moment, but you need to hand it to Mark — he doesn’t rest. He’s been reaching out to his contacts to see who might be interested in coming onto a future season. Specifically, he’s talking with cast members who haven’t done All Stars yet.

So far, he’s revealed four names. He’s gotten in contact with Coral, Davis, Mallory, and now Sarah Rice.

All of these people have the potential to be interesting returners, but Sarah’s change of heart is quite unexpected. She seemed adamant about avoiding the show after Johnny took her money on Rivals 3. Now, she feels ready to come back, and it’s at a very interesting time. We just saw All Stars Rivals, and it had a twist that was very similar to the money-stealing twist on Rivals 3.

Sarah said she’s excited about returning to All Stars because it feels like a game where the smartest person can actually win, but she also feels she’s in good physical shape. She recently underwent a full hysterectomy, which removed endometriosis that had caused her pain in the past.

Given the changes in her life, this could be an opportunity for Sarah to prove she’s still a physically and mentally fierce competitor. And maybe, she could bring a friend along. She remains very connected to some cast members. Particularly, she hosts the Brain Candy Podcast with Susie, and occasionally they invite former cast members onto the show.

Sarah’s return could signify that All Stars is pivoting back to its Real World and Road Rules roots (if season 6 happens). Ultimately, that decision is up to producers, but Mark is one of the executive producers on the show. He can’t make all the decisions, but he seems willing to be a liaison between fans and the crew. So far, the names he’s contacted are making viewers excited to see where All Stars 6 could go (again, if it happens).