Vets & New Threats has a cast packed with many of the show’s most popular faces. The veterans side has people like Bananas, CT, Ashley, and Aneesa — competitors who helped invent and reinvent the franchise. Then, we have a few fresher faces wearing the Veteran jersey.
While Olivia and Theo are newer recipients of the veteran title, they’re coming onto the season with a fresh relationship and they’ve been actively carving their legacy into the flagship series. Then, we have Michaela. She’s only done one main series show, Spies, Lies and Allies, and she was the first person out (though she followed it up with an impressive run on The Challenge: USA 2)
Looking at the season 41 cast, Michaela feels really out of place, but she also brings a level of excitement. When she debuted on Spies, Lies and Allies, she was a heavily requested Survivor crossover. Then, she went home first, disappointing many of viewers. Her performance on USA 2 renewed a lot of faith in her abilities, but that season had a very different political game than the flagship series. Her return on Season 41 will allow us to see if she can bring that level of competition to the main series.
Michaela’s return also feels very welcome because she wasn’t on Battle of the Eras. Most of the Challenge’s main veterans were on that season, but it’s nice to have some variety from that cast. Michaela isn’t the type of player who competes on every season, so she’s not overstaying her welcome like a lot of the other veterans on the show (not to name names).
There’s no reason Michaela shouldn’t be cast on the Challenge. She’s a great addition to the show, but is she a good fit for a season named Vets & New Threats?
This season appears to be in the same vein as Fresh Meat because it’s a 50/50 split of “veterans” and rookies. On Fresh Meat and Fresh Meat 2, there were fresh faces competing as “veterans” — think of the Austin kids on the first installment or Katelynn and CJ on the second edition.
War of the Worlds, another spiritual successor to Fresh Meat, also had some relatively new competitors compete as veterans. It was Paulie and Da’Vonne’s second season, and they were still labeled as veterans by production.
Michaela slides into this role on Vets & New Threats. She’s a veteran because production wants her to be, but she’s certainly not a seniored competitor.
Ultimately, production knows Michaela is popular in the Survivor world and fits well into the Challenge mold. She won’t do every season, so they snatched her up while they had the chance. Her position this season is fairly unique, but it gives her the opportunity to be the ultimate wild card in the game.
Stop Being Polite 