Challenge: All Stars 2

Challenge All Stars 2: Casting Rumors

Good news! It looks like All Stars 2 is in the early stages of production. Many old school names have been contacted, and Mark has assured fans they’re keeping this season all Real World/ Road Rules/ Fresh Meat.

The following people are being considered for the season. Huge thanks to Vevmo & Gamer as always!

All Stars 2 casting rumors and speculations.


Cohutta Grindstaff (The Real World: Sydney)

Eric Nies (The Real World: New York)- Could not do season 1 due to Real World: Homecoming/ COVID

Janelle Casanave (The Real World: Key West)

Jasmine Reynaud (The Real World: Cancun)

Jodi Weatherton (Road Rules: X-Treme)

Ryan Kehoe (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 1)

Sophia Pasqui (Road Rules: The Quest)

Tina Barta (Road Rules: South Pacific)- Was going to be on season 1. Rumored to have had positive COVID test.

Tyler Duckworth (The Real World: Key West)


Likely being considered by production, but not in the final stages yet.

Ace Amerson (The Real World: Paris)

Adam Larson (Road Rules: The Quest)

Angela Trimbur (Road Rules: X-treme)

Ashli Robson (The Real World: Sydney)

Ayanna  Mackins (Road Rules: Semester at sea)

Ayiiia Elizarras (The Real World: Cancun) 

Beth Stolarczyk (The Real World: Los Angeles)

Brad Fiorenza (The Real World: San Diego)

Brandon Nelson (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 2)

Brianna Taylor (The Real World: Hollywood)

Brittini Sherrod (The Real World: Hollywood)

Brooke LaBarbera (The Real World: Denver)

Cameran Eubanks (The Real World: San Diego)

Casey Cooper (The Challenge: Fresh Meat)

Chadwick Pelletier (Road Rules: Down Under)

Chet Cannon (The Real World: Brooklyn)

Christian “CJ” Koegel (The Real World: Cancun)

Dan Renzi (The Real World: Miami)

Dan Walsh (Road Rules: Viewer’s Revenge)

Danny Jamieson (The Real World: Austin)

Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

David Burns (The Real World: Seattle)

Derek Chavez (The Real World: Cancun)

Dunbar Merrill ( The Real World: Sydney)

Dustin Zito (The Real World: Las Vegas)

Elka Walker (The Real World: Boston)

Evelyn Smith (The Challenge: Fresh Meat)

Frank Sweeney (The Real World: San Diego 2)

Gladys Sanabria (Road Rules: Latin America)

Heather Cooke (The Real World: Las Vegas 2)

Heather Garner (Real World: New York)

Irulan Wilson (The Real World: Las Vegas)

Isaac Stout (The Real World: Sydney)

Jamie Murray (The Real World: New Orleans)

Jemmye Carroll (The Real World: New Orleans 2)

Jeremy Blossom (Road Rules: South Pacific)

Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio (The Real World: Key West)

Jonna Mannion (The Real World: Cancun)

Julie Stoffer (The Real World: New Orleans)

Katie Doyle (Road Rules: The Quest)

Kefla Hare (Road Rules: Down Under)

Kendal Sheppard (Road Rules: South Pacific)

Kimberly Alexander (The Real World: Hollywood)

Landon Lueck (The Real World: Philadephia)

LaToya Jackson (The Real World: St. Thomas)

Laurel Stucky (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 2)

Leah Gillingwater (The Real World: Paris)

Lori Trespicio (The Real World: Back to New York)

Mandi Moyer (The Challenge: Fresh Meat 2)

Marie Roda (The Real World: St. Thomas)

Marlon Williams (The Real World: Portland)

Melinda Stolp (The Real World: Austin)

Melissa Howard (The Real World: New Orleans)

MJ Garrett (The Real World: Philadelphia)

Norman Korpi (The Real World: New York)

Preston Charles (The Real World: New Orleans 2)

Robb Schreiber (The Real World: St. Thomas)

Roni Martin (Road Rules: Northern Trail)

Sarah Rice (The Real World: Brooklyn)

Shane Landrum (Road Rules: Campus Crawl)

Shauvon Torres (The Real World: Sydney)

Shavonda Billingslea (The Real World: Philadelphia)

Stephen Williams (The Real World: Seattle)

Steve Meinke (Road Rules: The Quest)

Susie Meister (Road Rules: Down Under)

Svetlana Shusterman (The Real World: Key West)

Teck Holmes ( The Real World: Hawaii)

Theo Gant (The Real World: Chicago)

Veronica Portillo (Road Rules: Semester at Sea)


Could change, but the following people are unlikely to be on the show.

Abram Boise (Road Rules: South Pacific)- Considered, but hurt his leg

Alton Williams (The Real World: Las Vegas 2)

Amaya Brecher (The Real World: Hawaii)

Angel Turlington (Road Rules: Viewers Revenge)

Anne Wharton (Road Rules: Northern Trail)

Blair Herter (Road Rules: The Quest)

Camila Nakawaga (The Challenge: Spring Break)

Cara Zavaleta (Road Rules: South Pacific)

Coral smith (The Real World: Back to New York)

Danny Roberts (The Real World: New Orleans)

Emilee Fitzpatrick (The Real World: Cancun)

Frank Roessler (The Real World: Las Vegas)

Jordan Wiseley (The Real World: Portland)

James Orlando (Road Rules: Maximum Velocity)

Jisela Delgado (Road Rules: The Quest)- Injured knee on All Stars 1

McKenzie Coburn (The Real World: New Orleans 2)

Nia Moore (The Real World: Portland)

Piggy Thomas (Road Rules: Down Under)

Rachel Robinson (Road Rules l: Campus Crawl)

Robin Hibbard (The Real World: San Diego)

Steven Hill (The Real World: Las Vegas)

Timmy Beggy (Road Rules: Second adventure)

Weston Bergmann (The Real World: Austin)

Zach Nichols (Real World: San Diego 2)

1 comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: