Challenge: Spies, Lies & Allies

The Challenge 37: Official Cast

The Official Cast for The Challenge season 37

It’s that time. The cast is getting ready to film the next Challenge season, but it’s going to be like the prior season.

This cast will need to quarantine before they can fly to another country and film. So, we are going to get some extra names on here who don’t make the final cast. If someone is removed from the final roster, I will remove them from the formal list.

Obviously, there will be cast spoilers. I will also post formatting spoilers, but not elimination spoilers.

Thank you Vevmo & Gamer

Challenge Name: Spies, Lies, and Allies

Location: Istria, Croatia

Host: TJ Lavin

Challenge 37 Cast

Amanda Garcia (Are You the One? 3)

Aneesa Ferreira (Real World: Chicago)

Ashley Mitchell (Real World: Ex-Plosion)

Ashley Mitchell Total Madness

Berna Canbeldek (Survivor Turkey)

Bettina Buchanan (Paradise Hotel Norge & Ex on the Beach Norge)

Big T (Shipwrecked UK)

Corey Lay (Twelve Dates of Christmas)

Cory Wharton (Real World: Ex-Plosion)

CT Tamburello (Real World: Paris)

Devin Walker (Are You the One? 3)

Emanuel Neagu (Survivor: Romania)

Emy Alupei (Survivor: Romania)

Esther Agunbiade (Big Brother Naija)

Fessy Shafaat (Big Brother 20)

Gábor “Gabo” Szabó (Warsaw Shore)

Hughie Maughan (Big Brother UK)

Jeremiah White (Love Island USA)

Josh Martinez (Big Brother 19)

Kaycee Clarke (Big Brother 20)

Kelz Dyke (Too Hot to Handle)

Kyle Christie (Geordie Shore)

Lauren Coogan (Love Island USA)

Logan Sampedro (Survivor Spain)

Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor)

Michele Fitzgerald (Survivor)

Nam Vo (Ultimate Beastmaster)

Nany Gonzalez (Real World: Las Vegas)

Natacha “Tacha” Akide (Big Brother Nigeria)

Nelson Thomas (Are You The? 3)

Priscilla Anyabu (Love Island UK)

Renan Hellemans (Ex on the Beach Double Dutch)

Tommy Sheehan (Survivor)

Tori Deal (Are You the One? 4)

Tracy Candela (Love Island Germany)


Jay Starrett (Survivor)

Wes Bergmann (Real World: Austin)- was never quarantining

Liv Jawando (Shipwrecked)

Michelle Schubert (Survivor)

Wendell Holland (Survivor)- was never quarantining

Ed Eason (The Circle)

Amber Borzotra (Big Brother); alternate

Amin Elkach (Love Island: Germany)

Mark Byron (Big Brother UK); alternate


After the second quarantine, the following people joined:

Amber Borzotra (Big Brother 16)

Ed Eason (The Circle)


  1. They are really choosing random people now, huh?!
    I mean, Michelle Schubert wasn’t even memorable on S33.

    I hope Natalie Anderson gets added to this list, so we’ll have a list of Survivor greats + Schubert!

  2. This is honestly the worst cast ever. Only 5 of these people were ever on real world. I like survivor but these are some of the most boring survivor players, with the exception of Michaela.

  3. It’s not even The Challenge anymore. More and more it’s people coming from other shows instead. You just need to do another Fresh Meat season instead of bringing people from other shows. Give the Fans a chance to get on. And please stop bringing “ football “ players persay. I mean it’s not really fair to the players trying to go up against someone that huge and a football player. And then making it a hall brawl for them on top of it. If it wasn’t for CT being on, I probably wouldn’t even watch next season. And I’ve seen every season. Josh and Fessy make me not want to watch it at all.

    1. YES!!!! They need a new castings process. They need to pull from MTV shows. Some awesome characters came from AYTO. I like the competition and athletic part of the show, but I need interesting personalities to watch. I wish they’d bring back Cara Marie.

    2. Thought I was watching The Challenge NOT Big Brother! No more JOSH. FOCUS MTV and let’s get back to The Challenge.!

  4. Why on Earth do they keep bringing Josh back? He talks like my toddler nephew and cries just as often as him.

  5. Ugh, still no Bananas, yet we get a bunch of randos who no one knows. I really wish we could go back to the Tony, Bananas, Wes, etc. days.

  6. Pretty awful cast overall, so many random people from random shows. There are so many amazing people they could bring on from the MTV family.

    But happy to see CT, Devin, Kyle, Cory & Nelly

  7. Horrible cast. If it’s just a bunch of randos, why even call it the Challenge. MTV alums is what made it the challenge. If those are fewer, just create a new show.

  8. Not looking foward to Amanda & Ashley being back on it.. everyone else, yes!! ESPECIALLY: CT, Kyle, Devin, Kyle, Nam , Tori, Jay & Wes!! … and all the love to TJ!

  9. Rinch and I give the cast 2 👎👎

    CT, and that’s it.

    Please only use Real World / OG Challenge cast.

    Nobody on the challenge goes on these other shows so why intermix


  10. How do they keep making female winners alternates? Put some respect on Jenny and Amber’s name

  11. There is no such thing as ex on the beach the Netherlands. The show is called ex on the beach double dutch, because it is a combination of people who are from the Netherlands and the dutch speaking part of Belgium. And Renan is actually from Belgium.

  12. I hate to say this but I think my days of keeping up with the challenge are almost over. I would be fine with the mostly rookie cast, but seriously…. WHO ARE ANY OF THESE PEOPLE?! Double agents did fine with casting bringing in 10 rookies most of whom we at least had some means of knowing about beforehand. But this hodge podge of random people from random reality shows in random countries is seriously ridiculous.

  13. Bring back the greats! Was excited to see All Stars but wasn’t all stars without Wes Bananas Cara Sarah Susie Evelyn Zach Abram Leroy, so many to choose from keep the greats in play. Instead of all these random. I can handle BB and Survivor but geez we have many option in our own country.

  14. It’s also not technically a “sport” either. The rules arent available for the players & are constantly changing. And this season ghis “sport” pits teams with different #s of players against each other. Shockingly the team with the most players wins each week. The only question each episode is “Will this be the week that someone invades the emerald team?” And ultimately, “Why didn’t they invade the emerald team?!!” Is that part of the game that viewers aren’t allowed to know about? Worst challenge season ever.

Leave a Reply to Anonymous Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: